AI Misuse by a Professor Delays Texas A&M Diplomas
Via Rolling Stone
The Story
Texas A&M University Commerce professor Jared Mumm delayed diplomas for a class of graduating seniors in May 2023 after improperly using ChatGPT to accuse them of submitting AI generated final essays.
Mumm copied student submissions into ChatGPT and asked the chatbot whether it had written them, telling the class bluntly that he does not grade AI work.
The method is fundamentally unreliable because ChatGPT is a text generator rather than a plagiarism detector and routinely claims authorship of human writing; when tested against Mumm's own doctoral dissertation, the chatbot said the passage could indeed have been generated by a language model.
Affected students received temporary X incomplete grades that held up their official diplomas even after they had walked at commencement.
Students fought back with Google Docs timestamps proving original authorship, at least one received an apology and was exonerated, and the university confirmed that no one failed the course or was barred from graduating.
The episode drew national attention as an early high profile example of educators misapplying AI tools and pushed the university to develop formal policies on AI detection.
Mumm copied student submissions into ChatGPT and asked the chatbot whether it had written them, telling the class bluntly that he does not grade AI work.
The method is fundamentally unreliable because ChatGPT is a text generator rather than a plagiarism detector and routinely claims authorship of human writing; when tested against Mumm's own doctoral dissertation, the chatbot said the passage could indeed have been generated by a language model.
Affected students received temporary X incomplete grades that held up their official diplomas even after they had walked at commencement.
Students fought back with Google Docs timestamps proving original authorship, at least one received an apology and was exonerated, and the university confirmed that no one failed the course or was barred from graduating.
The episode drew national attention as an early high profile example of educators misapplying AI tools and pushed the university to develop formal policies on AI detection.
Go Deeper
Read the original reporting at Rolling Stone.
Read Full Story at Rolling Stone →